The Common Level Ratio (CLR) is a crucial factor in determining the accurate value of real estate property in Pennsylvania. The CLR is a ratio that measures how a county’s base year assessments compare with current real estate market valuations. It is used to calculate the assessed value of a property, which in turn determines the amount of tax that needs to be paid on it.

Calculating the CLR can be a complex process, but it is essential for both property owners and the government to ensure that the tax assessments are fair and accurate. The CLR is calculated by comparing the assessed value of a property to its current market value, which is determined by the State Tax Equalization Board. The CLR is the ratio of the assessed value to the current market value used generally in the county as last determined by the State Tax Equalization Board.

In this article, we will explore how to calculate the Common Level Ratio and why it is important. We will also discuss the factors that affect the CLR and provide step-by-step instructions on how to calculate it. By the end of this article, you will have a clear understanding of how to calculate the CLR and why it is essential to ensure that your property is assessed fairly and accurately.

Understanding the Common Level Ratio

Definition of Common Level Ratio

The Common Level Ratio (CLR) is a measure used to compare the assessed value of a property with its current market value. It is defined as the ratio of assessed value to current market value used generally in the county as last determined by the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) [1]. In other words, the CLR is a tool used to equalize property assessments across counties in Pennsylvania, ensuring that property taxes are fairly distributed.

The CLR is calculated annually by the STEB, based on sales data compiled by the board. The board determines the arithmetic median of the individual sales ratios for every valid sale received from the county for the previous calendar year. The sales ratio is the assessed value of the property divided by its actual sale price [1]. The CLR is then applied to each property in the county to determine its fair market value for tax purposes.

Importance in Real Estate and Taxation

The CLR is an important factor in real estate and taxation in Pennsylvania. It is used to determine the fair market value of a property for tax purposes, which in turn affects the amount of property tax that must be paid. The CLR is also used in assessment appeals, where property owners can challenge the assessed value of their property [2].

In addition, the CLR is used in the calculation of the Pennsylvania Realty Transfer Tax, which is a tax imposed on the transfer of real estate. When preparing and filing a Pennsylvania realty transfer tax affidavit, it is necessary to report both the assessed value of the property and the common level ratio factor, which is based on the average ratio between the assessed value and fair market value of real estate in that county [3].

Overall, the CLR plays a crucial role in ensuring that property assessments and taxes are fairly and equitably distributed across Pennsylvania counties.

[1] PA Department of Community -amp; Economic Development
[2] Allegheny Institute for Public Policy
[3] Evans Estate Law Resources

The Mathematical Basis of Common Level Ratio

Fundamental Formulas

The Common Level Ratio (CLR) is a ratio that measures how a county’s Base Year Assessments compare with current Real Estate Market Valuations. The CLR is used to adjust property values for tax purposes, and it is calculated by dividing the assessed value of a property by the current market value. The CLR is expressed as a decimal or a percentage.

The formula for calculating the CLR is:

CLR = Assessed Value / Current Market Value

The CLR can also be expressed as a percentage by multiplying the result by 100:

CLR% = CLR x 100

Numerical Examples

To illustrate the calculation of the CLR, consider the following numerical examples:

Example 1:

Suppose a property has an assessed value of $100,000 and a current market value of $150,000. The CLR for this property is:

CLR = 100,000 / 150,000 = 0.6667

The CLR can also be expressed as a percentage:

CLR% = 0.6667 x 100 = 66.67%

Therefore, the CLR for this property is 66.67%.

Example 2:

Suppose a property has an assessed value of $200,000 and a current market value of $180,000. The CLR for this property is:

CLR = 200,000 / 180,000 = 1.1111

The CLR can also be expressed as a percentage:

CLR% = 1.1111 x 100 = 111.11%

Therefore, the CLR for this property is 111.11%.

These examples demonstrate that the CLR can be greater than or less than 100%. When the CLR is less than 100%, it means that the assessed value of the property is higher than the current market value. When the CLR is greater than 100%, it means that the assessed value of the property is lower than the current market value.

Data Collection for Calculation

Sources of Real Estate Data

To calculate the Common Level Ratio (CLR) for a specific county in Pennsylvania, the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) collects and analyzes data on real estate sales within that county. STEB then publishes the CLR for each county on or before July 1 of the year prior to the tax year on appeal before the board. This means that the CLR for the current year is based on real estate sales data from the previous year.

Real estate sales data is collected from various sources, including county assessment offices, real estate brokers, and the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). The sales data is then analyzed to determine the ratio of assessed value to current market value for each property sold. STEB uses this information to calculate the CLR for each county.

Assessment Records and Market Value

Assessment records are another important source of data for calculating the CLR. County assessment offices maintain records of the assessed value of all properties in their jurisdiction. This information is used to calculate property taxes based on the millage rate set by the local government.

Market value is the price that a property would sell for in the current real estate market. This value is determined by factors such as location, condition, and demand. Market value is not the same as assessed value, which is the value assigned to a property by the county assessment office for tax purposes.

To calculate the CLR, the assessed value of a property is compared to its market value. This ratio is then compared to the average mortgage payment massachusetts ratio of assessed value to market value for all properties sold in the county during the previous year. The resulting CLR is used to adjust the assessed value of properties in the county to reflect their current market value.

Overall, the process of collecting real estate data for the purpose of calculating the CLR is complex and involves multiple sources of information. However, the resulting CLR provides an important tool for ensuring that property taxes are based on fair and accurate assessments of property value.

Step-by-Step Calculation Process

Calculating the Common Level Ratio (CLR) requires a few steps. Here is a step-by-step process to help you understand how to calculate CLR.

Identifying Assessment Values

The first step is to identify the assessment values. Assessment values are the values assigned by the local government to a property for tax purposes. These values are often based on a percentage of the property’s market value.

Determining Market Values

The second step is to determine the market values of the properties in the county. Market values are the values that a property would sell for in an open market. These values can be determined by looking at recent sales of similar properties in the area.

Computing the Ratio

Once the assessment and market values have been determined, the CLR can be calculated. The CLR is the ratio of the assessment values to the market values. This ratio is used to ensure that properties are assessed fairly and accurately.

To calculate the CLR, divide the total assessed value of all properties in the county by the total market value of all properties in the county. This will give you the CLR for the county.

It is important to note that the CLR is used in the appeal process only, when a county’s Pre-Determined Ratio (PDR) differs more than 15%. The CLR is a ratio that measures how a county’s Base Year Assessments compare with current Real Estate Market Valuations.

By following these steps, you can calculate the CLR for a county.

Common Level Ratio Applications

Adjusting Property Taxes

Common Level Ratio (CLR) is an important factor in adjusting property taxes. It is a ratio that measures how a county’s base year assessments compare with current real estate market valuations. According to the Pennsylvania law, “Common Level Ratio shall mean the ratio of assessed value to current market value used generally in the county as last determined by the State Tax Equalization Board.”

CLR is used to adjust property taxes in Pennsylvania. If the CLR of a county is less than 100%, it indicates that the county’s assessments are below the market value. In such cases, the county’s tax assessment office may increase the assessments to match the market value. Conversely, if the CLR is greater than 100%, it indicates that the county’s assessments are above the market value. In such cases, the county’s tax assessment office may decrease the assessments to match the market value. The CLR is an essential tool in ensuring that property taxes are fair and equitable.

Evaluating Property Assessments

CLR is also used to evaluate property assessments. The State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) annually establishes the CLR of assessed value to current market value for each county in the Commonwealth utilizing statistically acceptable techniques, including sales ratio studies. The CLR is used to evaluate the accuracy of the county’s assessments.

If the CLR is significantly different from 100%, it indicates that the county’s assessments are not accurate. In such cases, the county’s tax assessment office may need to adjust the assessments to match the market value. The CLR is a valuable tool in ensuring that property assessments are accurate and fair.

In summary, the Common Level Ratio (CLR) is an essential tool in adjusting property taxes and evaluating property assessments. It ensures that property taxes are fair and equitable and that property assessments are accurate. The CLR is established annually by the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) for each county in the Commonwealth.

Challenges and Considerations

Variability and Time Lag

One of the main challenges in calculating the Common Level Ratio (CLR) is the variability and time lag in property assessments. The CLR is calculated by comparing the assessed value of a property to its current market value. However, the assessed value may not accurately reflect the current market value due to several factors, such as changes in the real estate market, property improvements, and errors in the assessment process. As a result, the CLR may not accurately reflect the current market value of a property, which can lead to inaccurate property tax assessments.

Moreover, there may be a time lag between the assessment and the calculation of the CLR. The CLR is typically based on the previous year’s sales data, which may not reflect the current market conditions. This can result in a delay in adjusting property tax assessments to reflect changes in the real estate market.

Legal and Regulatory Framework

Another challenge in calculating the CLR is the legal and regulatory framework surrounding property assessments. The CLR is regulated by the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB), which establishes the methodology for calculating the CLR and provides guidance to local assessors. However, the STEB’s methodology may not always align with the local real estate market conditions, which can lead to inaccurate CLR calculations.

Moreover, the legal framework surrounding property assessments may vary by state, county, and municipality, which can lead to inconsistencies in the assessment process. For example, some states may require annual property assessments, while others may require assessments every few years. Additionally, the assessment process may be subject to legal challenges, which can further delay the calculation of the CLR and lead to inaccurate property tax assessments.

Overall, calculating the CLR requires careful consideration of the variability and time lag in property assessments, as well as the legal and regulatory framework surrounding property assessments. By understanding these challenges and considerations, property owners and assessors can work together to ensure accurate property tax assessments that reflect the current market value of a property.

Review and Verification

After calculating the Common Level Ratio (CLR), it is important to review and verify the accuracy of the calculations. This section will cover two methods of review and verification: cross-checking calculations and professional appraisal and validation.

Cross-Checking Calculations

One method of verifying the accuracy of CLR calculations is to cross-check the calculations with other methods. For example, one can compare the CLR to the assessed value of a property and the current market value of the same property. If the CLR is accurate, it should reflect the difference between the assessed value and the current market value.

Another method of cross-checking is to compare the CLR to other properties in the same area. If the CLR is consistent across properties, it is more likely to be accurate.

Professional Appraisal and Validation

Another method of verifying the accuracy of CLR calculations is to seek professional appraisal and validation. This involves hiring a professional appraiser to assess the value of the property and compare it to the CLR. The appraiser can also provide an opinion on the accuracy of the CLR and suggest adjustments if necessary.

It is important to note that professional appraisal and validation can be expensive, and it may not be necessary for every property. However, if there is a significant discrepancy between the CLR and the assessed value or market value of a property, it may be worth considering professional appraisal and validation.

In summary, reviewing and verifying the accuracy of CLR calculations is an important step in ensuring fair and accurate property assessments. Cross-checking calculations and seeking professional appraisal and validation are two methods that can be used to verify the accuracy of CLR calculations.

Updates and Trends

Annual Adjustments

The Common Level Ratio (CLR) is subject to annual adjustments based on the real estate market conditions in each county. The State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) uses sales data compiled from each county to determine the CLR for the upcoming fiscal year. These adjustments help to ensure that the assessed values of properties in each county reflect their current market values.

Property owners should be aware that annual adjustments to the CLR can impact their property tax bills. If the CLR increases, it can result in a higher assessed value for their property, which can lead to an increase in property taxes. Conversely, if the CLR decreases, it can result in a lower assessed value for their property and a decrease in property taxes.

Impact of Market Fluctuations

The CLR is an important tool for ensuring that property assessments are fair and accurate. However, it is important to note that the CLR is subject to market fluctuations, which can impact its accuracy. In times of economic uncertainty, such as during a recession or housing market downturn, the CLR may not accurately reflect current market values.

Property owners should also be aware that the CLR may not accurately reflect the value of their property due to unique characteristics or market conditions. For example, if a property has recently undergone significant renovations or improvements, its assessed value may be higher than its market value. Conversely, if a property is located in an area with high demand, its assessed value may be lower than its market value.

In conclusion, property owners should stay informed about updates and trends related to the CLR to ensure that their property assessments are fair and accurate. They should also be aware of the impact of market fluctuations on the CLR and take steps to ensure that their assessed values reflect their property’s current market value.

Frequently Asked Questions

What steps are involved in calculating the common level ratio for real estate transactions?

To calculate the common level ratio, the State Tax Equalization Board (STEB) collects data on property sales and assessments. The ratio is then determined by dividing the assessed value of a property by its market value. This ratio is then used to adjust the assessed value of other properties in the same county to reflect their market value.

How can one apply the common level ratio in property tax assessments?

The common level ratio is used to ensure that property assessments are fair and accurate. By adjusting assessed values to reflect market values, the common level ratio helps to ensure that property owners are not unfairly burdened with high taxes.

What is the process for determining the common level ratio for a specific year, such as 2024?

The STEB determines the common level ratio for each county in Pennsylvania every year. This ratio is based on data collected from property sales and assessments in the previous year. The STEB then publishes the common level ratio for each county on its website.

How is the common level ratio utilized in Pennsylvania for tax purposes?

The common level ratio is used in Pennsylvania to calculate property taxes. When a property is sold, the common level ratio is used to determine the fair market value of the property. This value is then used to calculate the transfer tax owed on the sale. Additionally, the common level ratio is used to adjust assessed values to reflect market values, which helps to ensure that property owners are not unfairly burdened with high taxes.

What are the historical trends in the common level ratio for Pennsylvania counties?

Historically, the common level ratio has varied widely between counties in Pennsylvania. Some counties have had common level ratios above 1.0, while others have had ratios below 1.0. However, in recent years, the common level ratio has been closer to 1.0 for most counties.

How does one interpret the common level ratio figures in Allegheny and Butler Counties?

In Allegheny County, the common level ratio for 2024 is 1.03, which means that assessed values are slightly higher than market values. In Butler County, the common level ratio for 2024 is 1.00, which means that assessed values are equal to market values. It is important to note that the common level ratio is just one factor used to calculate property taxes, and other factors such as millage rates and exemptions also play a role in determining the final tax bill.